Commentary

May 23, 2002

by Barry Stagg

Vancouver College loses to Mount Cashel victims at Supreme Court of Canada

Excerpted from the SCC database:

Rowland v. Vancouver College Ltd.
(29000) (B.C.) May 23, 2002
[2001] S.C.C.A. No. 652 in the SCCA database.
Property law -- Trusts and trustees -- Ontario court granting leave to Applicant schools to bring petitions in British Columbia to determine ownership of their shares and nature and scope of any trust under which they are held -- British Columbia Court of Appeal affirming determinations made -- Whether Court of Appeal erroneously concluded that finding that shareholders held shares as representatives of religious order meant that religious order was real trustee -- Whether Court of Appeal erroneously concluded that private Act of Parliament incorporating entity could have effect of automatically replacing religious order as trustee.
HELD: The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

* Christian Brothers of Ireland in Canada (Re) (27958) (Ont.)
May 23, 2002
[2000] S.C.C.A. No. 277 in the SCCA database.
Property law -- Trusts and trustees -- Whether trust property can be used to satisfy claims occurring entirely outside of and separate from the trust simply because the trustee is liable for those claims -- Whether a charitable corporation is a single entity for the purposes of exigibility even where the charitable corporation is administering multiple, separate trusts -- Whether the winding-up of a charitable corporation effectively winds up or terminates the trusts for which it is trustee; or, in the alternative, whether the trust continues and the court retains its discretion to appoint a new trustee -- Whether, or in what circumstances, assets held by a charitable corporation in trust for a charitable object are directly exigible to satisfy the claims of tort claimants.
HELD: The application for reconsideration is dismissed.

Back to the Weekly Index